The North Water by
Ian McGuire
My rating:
4 of 5 stars
This book kept reminding me of The Terror by Dan Simmons. It has the same tone and both are about sea expeditions gone awry in the ice. Simmons was the better writer, but McGuire does a passable job. It’s also MUCH shorter and therefore much tighter. There is enough tension in the story to keep you turning the pages, and the ending is gratifying. Themes of redemption, fate, God, and morality against a backdrop of the crudeness and harshness of life on a whaling ship.
View all my reviews
The world we see with our eyes is not the whole truth. Dreams and visions are just as real as matter. What we can imagine or think exists as truly as anything we can touch or smell. Where do our thoughts come from, if not from God?” “They come from our experience,” Sumner says, “from what we’ve heard and seen and read, and what’s been told to us.” Otto shakes his head. “If that were true, then no growth or advancement would be possible. The world would be stagnant and unmoving. We would be doomed to live our lives facing backwards