The Calamity Club by
Kathryn Stockett
My rating:
2 of 5 stars
Kathryn Stockett is a great writer. She can write humor, create memorable characters, and hide history in a great story. Still, there is enough implausibility in this story to make it more of a tall-tale than historical fiction. Which I would be ok with if it didn't dress itself up to be pro-feminist when rather it undermines women in lots of ways. The villain is a woman who is portrayed as evil and vindictive despite her disappointments and betrayals. The answer to the main problem is
(view spoiler)[opening a brothel, which just subjugates women. If it was so noble why doesn't Charlie and Birdie turn tricks? All of the pros want to leave the profession and even if they are paid more under Charlie and Birdie they are still doing something they don't want to do if they could find a different profession. Why doesn't Charlie remake clothes or Birdie sell her cakes? Sure it wouldn't make as much but they could have everyone keep their self-respect. In the end, the men bail them out anyway. Which is a choice I don't understand that Stockett made if she was going to have the women provide their own solution. Why have Birdie's man dismiss the loan? Or Charlie's ex-lover give her an envelope of cash? And the fact that everyone is against this idea until they find out how much money it makes shows that all the characters are just willing to be bought off . The fact that Garnett doesn't find out with all the advertising going on, the taxis, the college boys and the music really stretches credibility. (hide spoiler)] Also, the build up to the main story is slow and simmering and then it rushes at the end and doesn't resolve some of the main conflicts
(view spoiler)[Are they just going to let Frances' husband languish in that institute? (hide spoiler)] I liked the era: I liked Birdie; I liked the exploration of different types of childlessness; I liked the humor. Meg was adorable even if her story seemed to be a little drawn out and arbitrary for her part she played. I wish I liked it more than I did.
View all my reviews
No comments:
Post a Comment